Skip to content

Our Story

A Cup of Joe, a Family Table, and a Line Out the Door

How a sister restaurant to Joey’s Pizza became one of Marco Island’s favorite places to start the day.

Walk down North Collier Boulevard on a Saturday morning in season and you can usually find Doreen’s Cup of Joe by the people waiting outside it. Some are holding coffee from the truck out front. Some are reading the menu on their phones. Most of them have been here before.

Next door to Joey’s

Doreen’s Cup of Joe belongs to Joe and Doreen Oliverio, the same family behind Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House, the Italian spot next door at 257 N Collier Blvd. State business records list the two of them as the managers of Doreeno LLC, the company behind the restaurant, which was formed in September 2012.

When the restaurant’s Facebook page went up, it introduced Doreen’s simply as “the newest breakfast and lunch spot opening in Marco Island,” and “a sister restaurant of Joeys Pizza.” By January 2014 the staff was thanking guests for joining them in their “first month of being open,” and that spring they signed off on their “first season on marco island” with a promise to see everyone over the summer.

Banana muffin and thick sliced bacon beside a turquoise Doreen’s Cup of Joe coffee cup

Breakfast, taken seriously

The menu reads like a family recipe box that kept growing. There are Belgian waffles and challah French toast, ten kinds of buttermilk pancakes, skillets and omelets, a section of Benedicts the kitchen calls “Eggs Bently,” and a full lunch menu of salads, sandwiches, tacos and burgers. Breakfast is served all day.

What sets it apart is what goes into it. Eggs are Eggland’s Best cage-free browns. The sausage is all natural, with no preservatives, from Bradley’s Country Store, a small family farm in Tallahassee. The maple syrup comes from Vermont, the milk from a farm in Myakka City, and the coffee from Kana Coffee, roasted in Miami. The orange juice is squeezed in house every day.

Marco Eagle food writer Will Watts has made a habit of coming back. In a 2021 column he called Doreen’s one of his favorites for breakfast on the island, and later that year he wrote about ordering a biscuit sandwich with a list of changes and getting exactly what he asked for. “In a world of ‘no substitutions,’” he wrote, “Doreen’s says, ‘no problem.’”

“Doreen’s says, ‘no problem.’”

A coffee truck, and a few neighbors

The restaurant has grown past its own four walls. A vintage coffee truck now parks outside, pouring coffee, espresso drinks, chai and tea, plus mimosas and Aperol spritzes, so the wait for a table goes a little easier. Up the block, the family added La Mesa, a Mexican restaurant at 297 N Collier Blvd, joining Joey’s and Doreen’s in a short stretch of the boulevard.

Joe Oliverio has also become a familiar voice at City Hall on a less delicious subject: housing for the people who work on the island. In 2024 he became the first business owner in the city to apply to convert second-floor office space into apartments under a new rule, with plans that included homes for his own employees.

Doreen’s mint green vintage coffee truck parked outside the restaurant

The same table, every morning

More than a decade on, Doreen’s carries a 4.6 rating across more than 2,600 Google reviews, and the advice from regulars has not changed: come early, try the fresh-squeezed orange juice, and leave room for pancakes.

Sources

  1. Doreen’s Cup of Joe, official website: https://doreenscupofjoemarco.com/
  2. Doreen’s Cup of Joe on Facebook (opening announcement and early posts, archived via a public mirror): https://www.facebook.com/1409439829274176 and https://toprestaurantsinusa.com/restaurant/doreens_cup_of_joe/1409439865940839/
  3. Florida business record for Doreeno LLC (filed Sept. 5, 2012; managers Joseph and Doreen Oliverio): https://bisprofiles.com/fl/doreeno-l12000113877
  4. Will Watts, “‘Watts for Dinner’: Doreen’s, the perfect place for a picky crowd,” Marco Eagle, Jan. 8, 2021: https://www.marconews.com/story/entertainment/2021/01/08/watts-dinner-doreens-perfect-place-picky-crowd/4138504001/
  5. Will Watts, “In a world of ‘no substitutions,’ Doreen’s says, ‘no problem,’” Marco Eagle, Dec. 10, 2021: https://www.marconews.com/story/entertainment/2021/12/10/watts-in-world-no-substitutions-doreens-says-no-problem/6423006001/
  6. Tim Aten, “New restaurants coming to East Naples, Marco Island,” Gulfshore Business, Jan. 27, 2023: https://www.gulfshorebusiness.com/editorschoice/tim-aten-knows-new-restaurants-coming-to-east-naples-marco-island/article_ac6c58e8-6136-57bc-a1d1-7958d7f6d30a.html
  7. J. Kyle Foster, “Marco Island restaurant owner files first application to remodel offices into housing,” Naples Daily News, Dec. 17, 2024: https://www.naplesnews.com/story/money/business/local/2024/12/17/marco-island-s-joeys-owner-files-to-turn-offices-into-apartments/76829835007/
  8. Kelly J. Farrell, “Marco Affordable Housing Options Remain Limited,” Coastal Breeze News: https://www.coastalbreezenews.com/news/city/marco-affordable-housing-options-remain-limited/article_739099a8-e6c9-11ee-9090-239e69babb20.html
  9. Marco Island Chamber of Commerce member listing: https://marcoislandchamber.org/members/doreens-cup-of-joe/

Checking the skyMarco Island, FL · Open daily 7:30 AM to 2:00 PM